book reviews |
book reviews |
Multi-volume author, Stephen Reeves introduces us to his latest fantasy story, the second volume in the Evercharm trilogy (ignore the volume number on the cover) “The Melody of Three”: Sorcerer Christaan De Rein's return to Liverpool does not go well, starting with the fact that his trusted apprentice, Higgins, dies on the way. Then again, Higgins dies a lot. Of course, Rein doesn't expect to be welcomed with open arms after being banished for nine years, but a cryptic summons from The Musician herself cannot go unanswered. But when Rein arrives all is in chaos. People with fairy blood are turning up dead. The Forum Magicae is undone and the Curators sieged. And in another world altogether, where Earth is just a legend, a girl named Niena and a cursed lyre hold the key to saving both realms. Or destroying them. This story drew me into its embrace in unexpected ways. I am not normally attracted to the darker side of fantasy. This story felt like it was in a perpetually dusk on a cloudy day. I had a hard time putting the story down, I was wooed and attracted like seldom before. The author’s grasp of language was breathtaking throughout. The images that unfolded in my mind were wonderfully intoxicating at times. Scene setting was extensive as fantasy usually is. Dialogue was terse and well played. The action could have been a bit fuller in a place or two, a few times I had to reread a section to be certain I didn’t miss a syllable. I award 4.8 stars to "The Melody of Three: (Evercharm Trilogy, Book 1). You can buy this book:
https://www.amazon.com/the-Melody of-Three-Evercharm-Trilogy-Book https://www.goodreads.com/-the-melody-of-three https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-melody-of-three-sd-reeves and other major platforms where you buy books. You can connect with the author: https://twitter.com/SD_Reeves https://www.facebook.com/SDReeves.Author https://www.goodreads.com/author/S_D_Reeves I have reviewed the first book of the Evercharm trilogy here: https://www.wordrefiner.com/book-reviews/curses-of-scale-by-s-d-reeves I have reviewed the third book of the Evercharm trilogy here: www.wordrefiner.com/book-reviews/a-song-in-the-dark tags: fantasy, fairy, fairies, magic, elf, elves, music, books, sculpture Copyright © 2020 Mark L Schultz except for the author's introduction
83 Comments
Mark
11/28/2020 12:13:27 pm
You are welcome, I really enjoyed reading your book.
Reply
11/28/2020 12:58:26 pm
Well, for starters I am a bit of the type of fellow who will read a book (say about pirates, or tall ships) then go off and carve a boat from a block of wood. Generally speaking, if I can picture something, I can usually make it. A bit crafty in that way.
Mark
11/28/2020 01:12:11 pm
That is a handy skill, being able to build what you can visualize.
Reply
11/28/2020 01:23:00 pm
Of course I haven't tried to make a working Death Star. Yet. Hmm.
Reply
Mark
11/28/2020 02:14:15 pm
Everyday responsibilities do get in the way of appreciating when you live in a special place. I have noticed the same thing about Oregon. There are so many special and interesting places all over the state. I have not visited many of them. 11/28/2020 04:36:54 pm
There is a Tolkein museum somewhere here I would love to see. Also a glacier. Many more, but those are the ones off the top of my head - and Switzerland is a small country.
Reply
Mark
11/28/2020 05:04:37 pm
A quarter of a century is a good start.
Reply
11/28/2020 05:32:13 pm
Reminds me a bit of how I work dialogue, and motivations; talking to the characters. I am surprised I haven't been locked up yet haha.
Mark
11/28/2020 06:06:51 pm
You were the IT guy on that job. I bet you have some funny stories to tell.
Reply
11/28/2020 06:17:59 pm
Several times I had to perform IT voodoo to get things running, often right before live show. I remember once I managed to get their CGs (computer graphics), camera control, and live broadcast back up and running about 10 seconds after things were supposed to start. There was a huge cheer, and I had to cold count down the swap to a live broadcast.
Reply
Mark
11/28/2020 10:49:07 pm
Details really make a difference, sometimes good and sometimes bad. The trick is to find the right balance, to provide enough detail for color and texture in the story, but too many and you have fallen into the dreaded infodump swamp. 11/29/2020 07:07:25 am
I definitely agree on that. Per the old adage descriptions and details can be like icing on the cake. A little, or moderate amount is nice. But too much will spoil it. It is something I have struggled with in the past.
Reply
Mark Schultz
11/29/2020 09:49:02 am
That was a good trick with the Latin and I think you pulled it off pretty well. I am reminded of the language touches that JRRT utilized in the LOTR. As a professor of languages he went far down the rabbit hole, inventing multiple languages and histories, in his spare time. That series was my introduction to high fantasy when I read it for the first time in junior high school. I loved it so much I read it two more times before graduating from high school. Before that I had read mostly science fiction.
Reply
11/29/2020 11:31:31 am
Thanks! We share that much in common. I am a big fan of Tolkien, and in high school I could speak Sindarin. Yes, I went all out. He was a huge influence on me.
Mark
11/29/2020 11:48:01 am
You are a big fan, no doubt about that. I didn't give much thought to trying to learn any of the languages.
Reply
11/29/2020 02:36:49 pm
Well, I had a spectacular disdain for my social life.
Reply
Mark
11/29/2020 05:15:08 pm
Spectacular disdain, what a great line! 11/29/2020 05:33:57 pm
Oh I agree, and thank you for the links!
Reply
Mark
11/29/2020 05:50:47 pm
Maybe I used the wrong term, categories, keywords might be better. Take a look at this article. Anne is another of my favorite bloggers and Dave is very smart and methodical. How to Change Your Kindle Keywords, by Dave Chesson
Reply
11/29/2020 06:02:17 pm
Ahh yes, I am afraid I don't have any control over those. Everything is entirely controlled by the publisher, and they have had only middling success - they don't operate directly through amazon, but via a third party. I am not precisely sure how it works. The only thing I can change is my author page.
Reply
Mark
11/29/2020 06:45:44 pm
I suppose this is a good argument for self-publishing, having complete control of your books. Traditional publishing, as an industry, is collapsing, and has been for the last several years. The big 5 publishers are about to be the big 4. We have Amazon to thank for that. Amazon made the gatekeepers of traditional publishing irrelevant and their profit margins have been shrinking ever since.
Reply
11/29/2020 07:11:16 pm
This is actually something I've been struggling with, at least when I consider the new series I am writing. On one hand, even a small-publisher lends a bit of credibility. Also, it is easier to get Bookbub slots and the like.
Mark
11/30/2020 09:32:48 am
You make some good points. Here is am answer to one of them possibly. Start your own imprint. https://www.janefriedman.com/why-self-publishing-authors-should-consider-establishing-their-own-imprint
Reply
11/30/2020 10:33:13 am
I've heard different opinions on that. I am still a few years away from releasing the new series, I think I will keep Evercharm where it is, and then re-evaluate later.
Reply
Mark
11/30/2020 10:54:22 am
Bookbub deal ads are hard get, I have read at least one blog to that effect. 11/30/2020 05:07:15 pm
Usually take forever. They are now mostly taken up by trad published titles. Very hard for indies to get in nowadays.
Reply
Mark
11/30/2020 05:26:52 pm
Rights, royalties and cumulative experience. That is a great list. I would add one thing, have any contract inspected by an attorney familiar with intellectual property rights and licensing before signing. Very obvious, I know, but it bears repeating. Too many authors have fallen for scams and lost everything, truly, the devil is in the details of a contract.
Reply
11/30/2020 05:35:24 pm
That is a solid suggestion. And for those who can afford it, I suggest signing up for something like the Author's guild. They provide a lot of good legal advice, among other things.
Mark
11/30/2020 06:17:45 pm
The Authors' Guild sounds like a good resource. I will check it out.
Reply
11/30/2020 06:24:20 pm
I used to read that blog of Strauss's, until I encountered her on Absolute Write forums. Not a friendly person, suffice to say.
Reply
Mark
11/30/2020 08:45:32 pm
I have not had the pleasure of meeting her outside of a blog, that I can recall. Some people are prickly, sometimes they are having a bad day. 12/1/2020 09:01:01 am
Probably a good thing to avoid that forum, then, hah. She is unique, I won't get into it though.
Reply
Mark
12/1/2020 09:39:37 am
I have heard of Bookbub, they are a fairly big player in the field, if you ignore the gorilla. The other two are new to me.
Reply
12/1/2020 10:59:17 am
They are the Apex predator. The other two are considered the next tier, but are magnitudes below.
Mark
12/1/2020 11:23:09 am
I find spelling errors all the time. It is part talent and part skill.
Reply
12/1/2020 11:55:26 am
I don't think the cost for the large print would be too bad, just a matter of convincing a publisher I suppose.
Reply
Mark
12/1/2020 02:39:05 pm
A publisher won't do anything that won't add to their bottom line. 12/1/2020 05:39:23 pm
I would have to check, I know an audiobook is licensed. But we worked something out.
Reply
Mark
12/1/2020 06:06:45 pm
The Hobbit is pretty wild reading for a five-year-old boy. I was introduced to The LOTR trilogy when I was in the eighth grade, I think I found the Hobbit a year later, in the library.
Reply
12/1/2020 07:03:54 pm
I read quite a bit at an early age, then dropped off later. Now, doing so again. I don't believe I touched the LOTR trilogy until much later.
Mark
12/1/2020 08:19:48 pm
I learned to read at five years of age, I was reading the Dick and Jane books. I was taught to read by a neighbor who lived on the other side of our back fence. She was a retired school teacher, and she made it fun for me.
Reply
12/2/2020 06:01:17 am
Ahh! I see how the seeds of the future word-refiner were sown!
Reply
Mark
12/2/2020 09:37:30 am
I never connected those particular dots. I have known that I can focus a lot of my concentration, especially when reading, to the exclusion of almost everything around me. I recall things I have read much easier than if I hear them. Hearing things don't rank very high on my list of priorities, it seems, without a lot of repetition. I have felt my brain is wired somewhat differently than others. 12/2/2020 10:38:23 am
I tend to be very visual. Anything told to me, especially directions, can get me confused easily enough. More or less I tend to view being called Autistic as a label for other folks to understand how I work.
Reply
Mark
12/2/2020 11:15:55 am
I have struggled all of my life with spoken directions to get somewhere. I have always depended on maps and then electronic navigators such as Garmin when I started working in construction. I am visually oriented also.
Reply
12/2/2020 01:57:01 pm
People can tell me to raise my right hand, and I may raise my left. Depends on all the other noise, and interference happening, though.
Mark
12/2/2020 04:20:23 pm
I half expected you to say that because your descriptions were very good and rather lengthy at times. I know I will find that when reading fantasy, it seems to be a hallmark of the genre.
Reply
12/2/2020 08:16:19 pm
It seems to be a common issue, at least. Especially among folks who grew up reading certain authors.
Reply
Mark
12/2/2020 11:09:28 pm
I read a lot of Asimov when I was young. I recall Frank Herbert having some lengthy descriptions also. In the 80s I read the rest of the Dune series, up to number 9 at the time, I think. His son was writing then. It got pretty weird about that time. Bringing down a galactic empire is a hard act to follow.
Reply
12/3/2020 07:52:18 am
Would be tough shoes to follow. And on saving things, yeah I agree. My organization is a bit half-hazard when it comes to my writing, though.
Mark
12/3/2020 09:40:06 am
Action beats can carry the story forward in a seamless fashion, when they are done well. However, I think that dialogue tags are necessary and can be used for emphasis.
Reply
12/3/2020 06:19:39 pm
I really appreciate that, even with all the work, it is difficult to know if a character in the end connects. What you have in your head, is obviously different than what others see, and all that.
Reply
Mark
12/3/2020 10:07:22 pm
I have heard it said that no two people read the same book in the same way. The book is different for each person. I think it is true, because each person is in a different mind with a different background. 12/4/2020 10:07:33 am
Quite so, we are all special snowflakes, as the saying goes.
Reply
Mark
12/4/2020 10:26:16 am
A friend of mine was pretty good with Wordstar in the early 80s. He showed me how it worked. I decided to hang on to my typewriter. The WYSIWYG idea hadn't caught on yet. There was no fancy GUI. It was all monochrome screens and DOS. I hope I used all those terms correctly, it has been so long.
Reply
12/4/2020 02:20:15 pm
I used DOS quite a bit, growing up. I am not terribly well versed with it anymore, neither that nor Basic programming. I am having to relearn a lot of things.
Reply
Mark
12/4/2020 03:08:44 pm
Rein was insufferably selfish, that is quite a chink in the good-guy armor. Chancy is funny at times, almost cute with his humor. his devotion to the rules borders on psychopathic.
Reply
12/4/2020 07:02:17 pm
I have heard of Grendel, but I haven't checked it out. I think those sort of books were in fashion ten years ago, like Wicked, and such.
Reply
Mark
12/4/2020 08:49:57 pm
I think I read Grendel in the 80s. It seemed revolutionary to me at the time, to write a story from the antagonist's point of view. Now I know that every well-written antagonist thinks they are the hero in their story.
Reply
12/5/2020 08:36:31 am
I have so many, so many books I need to read. And more keep coming in for reviews, hah.
Reply
Mark
12/5/2020 09:26:44 am
A lot of people like to get outside for lots of reasons. Some authors use outdoor activity as a way to refresh their creative mind or muse.
Reply
12/5/2020 06:25:12 pm
Changing settings can have profound effects. I do enjoy writing in an 18th century member library in Basel, when I can. Covid put a damper on it.
Mark
12/5/2020 06:39:31 pm
That library would be lovely to work in. In the summer of 74 I was backpacking around western Europe, studying architectural history and there was plenty to see. Lots of cathedrals and castles. Traveling 2nd class on my student rail pass was pretty good.
Reply
12/6/2020 11:10:30 am
It is right near the Munster in Basel, in the oldest part of town. Lovely and peaceful. Well the library is, there are a lot of tourists outside.
Reply
Mark
12/6/2020 11:18:51 am
Tourists are not very peaceful, no question about that. They are having fun and making memories to last them the rest of their life. 12/6/2020 11:26:50 am
They sometimes have events up there, which is worse.
Reply
Mark
12/6/2020 11:33:09 am
An event would be disturbing for anyone seeking a quiet place.
Reply
12/6/2020 11:53:15 am
Can't say there are. Other than perhaps, Tolkien. But even then, not really.
Mark
12/6/2020 12:35:43 pm
The author leaves fingerprints all over the book. A dozen authors if given the same prompt will write at least twelve different stories.
Reply
12/6/2020 12:47:02 pm
Quite so. Even for those authors that churn out books.
Reply
Mark
12/6/2020 01:27:55 pm
Scrivener is an amazing program, by all reports. It sounds very powerful to me. However, it also has a steep learning curve. There are a lot of authors that love that program. It has been reviewed by a lot of authors also.
Reply
12/6/2020 01:31:36 pm
That's the thing, I may use it for another series, but I don't think I could do it midway. I have to keep to my old system.
Reply
Mark
12/6/2020 08:51:21 pm
One author told me he outlined his book after it was written, it made it easier to search for a particular scene. That trick saved him a lot of time in the long run.
Reply
12/7/2020 10:21:31 am
That actually is an option that might work for my style. I will have to remember to do that, summarize or something.
Reply
Mark
12/7/2020 10:34:40 am
That sounds like a nice desk. Does it have any secret compartments?
Reply
12/7/2020 02:09:14 pm
Unfortunately not, but there is a big enough space that there might have been.
Mark
12/7/2020 02:21:55 pm
I had a desk with a false bottom in one drawer. The space was only about an inch deep, but it was fun.
Reply
12/7/2020 05:33:02 pm
It highlights the importance of fleshing out a character. Usually for me, they come long before the story.
Reply
Mark
12/7/2020 06:09:42 pm
If the characters are real, organic and relatable, then the setting and plot are merely vehicles to get them to the end of the story. The characters make all the difference in the world. 12/7/2020 06:57:49 pm
I totally agree. A lot of authors forgo characterization and such in favour of non-stop action. While that has its place, I personally gravitate towards deeper text.
Reply
Mark
12/7/2020 07:04:31 pm
I know one author who complained that her best ideas came in the shower and she lost so many of them by the time she was able to get out to write them down. I told her to get a Space pen and a small notebook of waterproof paper. That way she could jot it down without leaving the shower. She was very grateful
Reply
12/7/2020 07:13:42 pm
Very clever!
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Who am I?An avid reader, typobuster, and the Hyper-Speller. I am a husband, father, and grandfather. Archives
October 2024
Categories |
|
"I'm very pleased with all your efforts. Twitter promotion and proofreading were beyond what I expected with a book review. Your suggestions throughout the process of refining both books helped me immensely. I look forward to working with you again." A.E.H Veenman “Dial QR for Murder” and “Prepped for the Kill”
|