The year 2018 will herald the 200th anniversary of Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley's Frankenstein, or The Modern Prometheus. The timing seems right for the story of a real monster. German-born immigrant Anton Probst arrived in New York in 1863. Within two hours of his arrival he enlisted in the Union Army. During the American Civil War, Probst bore witness to mankind's brutality. Afterwards, he became an inmate at the disreputable Blockley Almshouse in Philadelphia.
Frankenstein was first conceived by Shelley in 1816. Her monster was an embodiment of abandonment and loneliness, feelings Shelley shared. In despair, the creature resorted to violence. Fifty years after Frankenstein's conception, Anton Probst adopted characteristics of Shelley's monstrous creation. He became Philadelphia's first mass-murderer when he slaughtered members of the Christopher Dearing family.
After his death, Probst's story continued. The creature that he had become left a deep impression on the people of Philadelphia and New York. Researchers used Anton Probst's body to show the effects of galvanization, the same means by which Frankenstein's monster stirred to life. Incredibly, similarities surface between Shelley and her circle, her monster, and events that transpired when the blood of innocents was shed an ocean away. One defining difference is present. Unlike Shelley's creature, the story of America's monster is very real.
I was pleasantly surprised to realize my assumption was wrong, this book is a comparison of the nameless monster created by Dr. Frankenstein and a German-immigrant mass-murderer in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, after the Civil War.
Even though the subject matter is quite grisly, leading up to the brutal death of a family, the writing is superb. Patricia has done an amazing amount of research and has woven a wonderful mix of reality and fiction, drawing staggering parallels between the two. I love knowing details and backstory behind significant events, and Patricia delivers a huge portion for all aspects of the major characters and driving forces. Patricia kept my attention the entire time, she moved the narrative along at a good pace and the focus never waned. There is also an extensive section of notes and source material, for those who wish to really dig in.
I award 4.8 stars to The Face of a Monster: America’s Frankenstein! The score would have been higher except for the handful of spelling issues I found.
You can follow Patricia Earnest Suter:
Tags: Murder, true crime, trial procedures, police procedures, mayhem, 19th century, immigrant, immigration