book reviews |
book reviews |
Multi-volume, multi-series, mystery author, Marni Graff introduces us to the fifth volume in The Nora Tierney English Mysteries series, “The Evening’s Amethyst”: Who is Verity? That becomes the central question for American writer Nora Tierney, who has moved to her new Oxford home with her fiancé, DI Declan Barnes, and her young son. Declan's new case at Exeter College coincides with a frantic call from Nora's stepsister, Claire Scott: a fellow graduate student has died in a fall, and Claire begs Nora to help her prove her friend didn't commit suicide. The sisters conduct their own snooping, while Declan and his tam juggle this death with a cold case that proves to be more surprising than Declan could ever imagine. I love Nora, don’t tell my wife or Declan. Her supporting cast adds so much depth to the story. Her life seems to be on the upswing in many ways. The author is very talented in weaving multiple stories into a cohesive and interesting plot! I was on the edge of my Kindle much of the way. The characters seem alive and quite three-dimensional. They struggle with everyday stresses and have worries just like us. Even the minor characters seem very organic in the story. A lot of the dialogue is witty and sometimes it is heartbreaking. The investigation proceeds at a reasonable pace and every step is realistic. I award 5 stars to "The Evening's Amethyst"! You can buy this book:
https://smile.amazon.com/Evenings-Amethyst-Tierney-English-Mysteries-ebook https://www.goodreads.com/-the-evening-s-amethyst You can follow the author: https://twitter.com/GraffMarni http://www.auntiemwrites.com http://facebook.com/bluevirginmysteries Tags: amateur sleuth, police procedural, women sleuths, dogs, toddler, action, mystery, suicide or murder, England, Oxford I reviewed other books by Marni: “Death at the Dakota” and interviewed her beneath that review: https://www.wordrefiner.com/book-reviews/death-at-the-dakota-a-trudy-genova-manhattan-mystery-book-2-by-m-k-graff “The Golden Hour” we had an interview there also: https://www.wordrefiner.com/book-reviews/the-golden-hour-by-marni-graff Copyright © 2021 Mark L. Schultz except for the author’s introduction
43 Comments
Mark
10/31/2021 09:17:13 am
You are welcome. You wrote an excellent book and I really enjoyed it.
Reply
10/31/2021 07:59:15 pm
The only time I've written a throwaway character who became something more was in the first book, The Blue Virgin. A friend of Nora's best friend, known for her shortbread, soon becomes known for something much more. In the first draft, this gal was just a red herring character. But by the end of that draft, I realized this person had a far better motive to be the baddie, instead of the person I'd initially chosen. So far, six more mysteries in, that hasn't happened again! But I've learned that my opening plot outline is just that, an outline, and to allow for happenstance if something better comes along!
Reply
Mark
10/31/2021 08:06:45 pm
I find that so interesting how that minor character became so important. I find it very interesting and many authors have reported similar events occurring in their writing.
Reply
11/1/2021 01:00:18 pm
Third person is most commonly used because it allows the write the most latitude, acting as an omniscient observer to everything that occurs. A character may not be aware of something that the author shows the reader in another scene. Second person is difficult to write well and most readers are not fans of it. First person brings the reader the closest to the character, inside his/her head. But the caveat there is that the author can only show the reader what that character can see. That can present a difficulty depending on the type of novel being written. I chose to keep the Nora Tierney series in third person, so while the majority of scenes are from Nora or Declan's POV, there are also scenes from secondary characters sprinkled in. However, in the Trudy Genova Manhattan Mysteries, a newer series, I decided to challenge myself and write Trudy's scenes in first person, and those from Ned, her detective boyfriend, in third. That varies the scenes and works for that series well, to my mind. Sometimes when a writer is struggling with a new book, it may help to rewrite a scene that's in first in third, or the converse, and see if that works better to the writers' ear.
Reply
Mark
11/1/2021 01:36:28 pm
Third person is very common and makes a lot of sense for beginning authors.
Reply
11/1/2021 03:00:15 pm
I read from an early age on, thanks to a mother who read to me every day. That allowed me to already be reading well when I entered kindergarten. So I have always had an affinity for books, words, and reading. In school, writing essays or stories was always a joy for me, not the chore it was for other friends. But I had a successful career as a nurse for 30 years, I always wrote "on the side" for a nursing journal and other articles. So I think I have a natural inclination toward writing. I'm the person who can't go to a lecture of any kind without taking notes!
Reply
Mark
11/1/2021 03:25:45 pm
We both had a mother that read to us and we both had an affinity for words at an early age. I started school in the first grade and was already reading at the third grade level.
Reply
11/1/2021 05:05:51 pm
For me, the easiest part would probably be when I'm gathering the ideas and doing the research before I plunge into the actual writing. I'm sorting out the setting, and distances from each place where my characters will travel to and from; I'm deciding on where certain scenes I know I'll need will be set and researching areas; I'm deciding on characters who will be new to the series for this particular one and giving them backgrounds. I'm choosing and learning and discerning in a way I find fascinating that leads up to the first draft. Not all of the research and pre-writing makes it into the book. To do that would make it sounds like a travelogue in places and an armchair psychologist in others. But it's the part that takes me places and allows me to flex my fictional muscles and therefore the most fun for me, along with playing the "What if?" game with the plot.
Reply
Mark
11/1/2021 05:12:57 pm
You make the research sound like fun. I know I would enjoy it, I love running down rabbit trails.
Reply
11/2/2021 10:32:01 am
I probably rewrite the opening pages at least three times; and then tweak more in subsequent rounds of polishing. This is the part that gets changed the most for me. Sometimes I’ll realize the story needs to start earlier. Other times I may start it later and fill in the earlier thread in a conversation or character’s thought. And as with The Evening’s Amethyst, on occasion I’ll bring forward a later scene and use that to kick off the action.
Reply
Mark
11/2/2021 12:00:33 pm
I think most writers are like you, they labor over the first line, page and even the first chapter. For good reason, an author has a brief window to hook the reader.
Reply
11/2/2021 02:46:53 pm
I was writing a feature column for the NY version of Nursing Spectrum. One month my article was about the Look Good, Feel Good program, which offered wigs and makeup lessons for women undergoing cancer treatment. The makeup was designed to disguise sallow or pale skin, hide deep, under-eye circles and such. Wigs allowed women who’d lost their hair to feel more like themselves, especially when they had young children home; or provided a chance to experience a completely different style or color, tiny bit of wildness.
Reply
Mark
11/2/2021 02:53:47 pm
That is a marvelous way to learn that you have some ability to write. It sounds like many were touched deeply.
Reply
11/2/2021 09:29:22 pm
I don't mention a specific clan, just say 'tartan' and leave it up to the reader's imagination. I don't even have that dog! Ours are Australian Labradoodles. But I've always loved the jaunty look of a Scottie dog and my Christmas dishes have a plaid ground with a black Scottie in the center. So I put one in the first book and it just became a thing...
Reply
Mark
11/3/2021 08:54:46 am
I love that idea of the undeclared tartan and a Scotty dog. Extra mystery at no charge!
Reply
11/3/2021 04:43:35 pm
There are two main messages that are takeaways from The Evening's Amethyst. One is that obsession, of any kind, usually doesn't end well. The main plot has that echoed in the subplot twice, first with the kidnapped baby, and then with the family member of different character who became carried away when he lost the woman he loved.
Reply
Mark
11/3/2021 06:12:23 pm
Obsession is a dangerous thing. It's very easy to perseverate over something so important to you that may mean little to nothing to other people.
Reply
11/3/2021 06:53:19 pm
Hmm, that's a question that I had to think about. There's no question good marketing will bring a mediocre book to more people's attention, that sort of 'let's see what the buzz is all about" factor at first; but the word-of-mouth will be lost and the reviews will be poorer when readers who do bother soon realize the goods are not there and are loathe to push that book on to others. So good marketing can only retrieve a poorer book so far, in my opinion.
Reply
Mark
11/3/2021 07:55:23 pm
Good marketing will get the horse out of the gate, but a weak horse will not place well at all. You are very right. Disappointed readers will leave poor reviews or no review at all.
Reply
11/4/2021 07:05:47 pm
I actually do quite a lot before I plunge into writing. I keep a running log of my recurring characters, so that I know what color I've made Declan's eyes to start, for instance, and did extensive bibles on he and Nora and a bit less for others who recur, like her friend, Val. These are backgrounds, family life, schooling, personality, etc. For each new book, I know some of the new characters I'll need and design them with a similar but not-as-extensive background. Maybe a page or two. Knowing where a character came from, what their family situation was, really sets them up for me in terms of how they will react in certain situations. I have a personality trait book I use, to, which gives helpful psychological insights. So I do all of that in my research phase before I start writing. When a character comes up during the writing, I do a timeout and make up a briefer background for them, depending on how much they will appear. Of course, not every single character needs this, like a waitress seen once or a porter who gives information, but any who give clues or plot points have at least some kind of background developed for them. I've found it helps with dialogue, too. For instance, in this book, there is an Irish scout who is only in one scene, a long one where she talks about the other students on the wing where the victim lived. I did research on Irish slang and dropped a few phrases into her dialogue so she would sound authentic without hitting the reader over the head with too much in the way of colloquialisms. Sometimes in the research phase I will see a photo in a magazine of an interesting face and tape that up to refer to for a character. I did that for Claire, Nora's stepsister, and had the photo in my folder as I was writing the prior Trudy book, but that image was there when I was developing her background, and that solidified Claire to me in my mind.
Reply
Mark
11/4/2021 07:19:50 pm
You have a great system in place. It's necessary when a series is being written. Without a character profile in place little errors such as eye color are bound to creep in.
Reply
11/5/2021 02:48:02 pm
The majority of my characters are from my imagination. I think about what that characters purpose is, and try to develop a well-rounded person readers can identify with--even when I wrote a psychopath in The Golden Hour, I had him remembering to call his gardener back in Russia to prune his roses! Even a psychopath can have one thing he loves, and if it's a ruthless disregard for humans, in this case it is his garden. On occasion I have used a habit or facial expression from someone I know, but mostly my characters are from the crazy recesses of my mind.
Reply
Mark
11/5/2021 04:07:36 pm
I recall that from The Golden Hour. It had exactly the intended effect. The character was more human than previously and changed the complexion of the story a little. I thought it was a nice touch.
Reply
11/5/2021 08:49:57 pm
I've been able to turn to writing and studying writing since 2000, after years of writing part-time. I finally retired from nursing, leaving on a high note after what would turn out to be my favorite job, the one I gave to Trudy Genova, as a medical consultant for a NY movie studio. Since I wasn't in the city every day, I went back to school a few years before that and got a degree in English Lit. The summer of 2000 I was able to study at Exeter College in Oxford, Gothic Literature and that was when I decided to set my budding mystery series there, with an American who lives in England. I plunged into full time writing, excited to finally be working at the career I'd always promised myself I would have. Still, I studied the craft of writing while learning how to research and design a novel. I took classes at the University of Iowa Summer Writing Festival, in several modalities, including writing mysteries and one for novelists. Meanwhile, I started writing The Blue Virgin and in 2003 working with a writing group I still workshop drafts with every summer. When I finished the first Nora Tierney book, I found an agent, and set about writing the next one. He wasn't able to sell that book at first; but then one of the writers in my group started her own indie press, Bridle Path Press, and I finally brought out The Blue Virgin in 2010. And I've never looked back, bringing out another Nora Tierney every 18 months or so and now alternating them with the Trudy Genova's. So far there are 5 in the Nora Tierney series, and I'm currently writing the 3rd in the Trudy's. So 7 books in 11 years isn't bad.
Reply
Mark
11/5/2021 08:57:38 pm
How nice that Trudy could take over your old job! A perfect example of writing what you know.
Reply
11/6/2021 01:41:38 pm
If I didn't write, I think I would invest time in learning about photography. I'm drawn to images captured, especially in black and white, and indeed all of the covers for the Trudy Genova series are photos. The first, Death Unscripted, is a classic Manhattan skyline. I wanted readers to pick up the book and know they were going to New York City. The second, Death at the Dakota, has an image of that famed NY landmark, and apartment building that has housed celebrities and millionaires. It's where John Lennon was living when he was killed, it has a long history. A friend of mine who takes wonderful photos took several of the outside of the building. I chose the one I liked and we cropped it to the image of the outside facade with its turrets and crenellations. When we put it into black and white, the cloudy sky that day gave the image an ominous feeling that I love. So photography greatly interests me.
Reply
Mark
11/6/2021 01:49:51 pm
We have the love of photography, in general, and black-and-white photography in particular in common. My bio-dad was a professional photographer, I learned a great deal about composition and darkroom work from him.
Reply
11/6/2021 04:28:12 pm
I don't right now. I used to read a ton of them and then found myself getting lost in experimental literature. I'm a classics kind of gal. Give me story with a beginning, middle and end, particularly a satisfying one. Once the books started coming, I found I had enough to do writing, researching and doing marketing work on my own books. I do read a lot, though. About three novels a week, mostly crime, but others, too, to vary it up. Reading other crime writers seems a far better use of my reading time, as I'm not going to writing for journals and by reading what's done well in crime, or even not, I learn from other writers in the genre.
Reply
Mark
11/6/2021 04:52:53 pm
I agree with you. I like a story to begin, take me somewhere I am not and them drop me off on my porch. Entertainment, struggle, resolution are all important. I don't read to be talked down to or be browbeat.
Reply
11/6/2021 08:26:09 pm
I was always drawn to mysteries, starting with Nancy Drews and Cherry Ames. My father would be so frustrated with me, as I'd get my weekly allowance on a Friday and run to the local stationary store to buy the next Nancy Drew. Then I'd read it that night and again over the weekend. "Now you've spent all your money in one place and don't have anything for the entire week," he'd complain, not being a reader. 'Oh, but I have my new book." I'd find things I'd missed on the first read with a subsequent read or two. I think the idea of a puzzle intrigued me, and I thought I could be clever and figure out before the end who the culprit might be. The more I read, the more I could see where writers played fair with the reader (and even more when they didn't!) in giving clues that were there but might be missed. I started reading Agatha Christie when I was about 9, as I read far above my grade level, and quickly ate them up!
Reply
Mark
11/7/2021 07:41:06 am
We have much in common. I was reading far above my grade level also. But I was buying comics. I had several relatives that were sending me books to read. I tended to reread the books more often than the comics.
Reply
11/7/2021 01:42:26 pm
My family always knew of my desire to be a full time writer, from my studying and writing part-time. I was always the one who was asked to check over essays and creative writing for edits. So they knew my eventual goal was to write full-time. My husband has always been incredibly supportive of my dream; I am so fortunate to have him in my corner.
Reply
Mark
11/7/2021 01:59:30 pm
Your creative writing bent was set at a very young age. Many take a long time to discover their creative purpose in life.
Reply
11/7/2021 03:57:19 pm
I am excited at each stage of a new book. I've found that always having the next on in progress at some stage means I never had nothing to do, so that in itself helps to maintain a certain level of excitement. Then, too, when a new book is out, I am anxious to share it with readers, so that is a high excitement time. Each new book is like birthing a baby!
Reply
Mark
11/8/2021 08:44:04 am
Working on multiple projects is a great idea to keep the excitement going for a writer. I have heard it's also a cure for writer's block most of the time. If the muse is silent on one book working on another can get the creative juices flowing again.
Reply
11/8/2021 09:15:18 am
I think I'll answer the last question first: I would get the cover done early as I did this time so that I can start pre-pub word going before the book is actually out. It gives readers of the series something to look forward to and keeps them apprised of where I'm going.
Reply
Mark
11/8/2021 10:29:22 am
Having the cover made early is a good idea. I have seen some authors take that step to the next level. They hold a contest for their readers to help choose the next cover. Usually there are minor differences among the two or three choices. These kind of things help knit the fans closer to the book and the author.
Reply
11/8/2021 03:47:04 pm
I’ll keep writing and you keep on helping writers get their best books out! Your edits really picked up on things I’d missed and made TEA a better book!
Reply
9/22/2023 12:04:42 pm
Who designed your website. I think you did a good job.
Reply
Mark
9/22/2023 08:01:17 pm
Thank you. Weebly let me choose from a large design selection and I took it from there.
Reply
9/22/2023 12:10:26 pm
You did a good job, in my opinion. Excellent post; I'll look into this further.
Reply
Mark
9/22/2023 08:03:12 pm
Thank you. I have not seen this interview format anywhere else.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Who am I?An avid reader, typobuster, and the Hyper-Speller. I am a husband, father, and grandfather. Archives
September 2024
Categories |
|
"I'm very pleased with all your efforts. Twitter promotion and proofreading were beyond what I expected with a book review. Your suggestions throughout the process of refining both books helped me immensely. I look forward to working with you again." A.E.H Veenman “Dial QR for Murder” and “Prepped for the Kill”
|