book reviews |
book reviews |
Multi-volume, historical-fantasy author, Jay Veloso Batista introduces us to the fourth volume in his wonderful series, “Kara, Shieldmaiden of Eire”: Battles and adventure crisscross the Viking Age! From monumental sea clashes to beleaguered mountain strongholds to war with the tribes of Eire, circumstance drives the scattered Agneson clan across the known world. And beyond the lands of Midgard, mythic hidden folk challenge our forerunner hero. The award-winning Forerunner Series epic continues…. Fleeing an arranged marriage, Kara escapes across the narrow sea to follow her warrior dreams. Escaping slavery, Cub joins Rollo’s horde in Britany, while his outlawed brother Sorven fights for survival in the Welsh mountains. Uncle Karl and his warriors rally to Harald Tanglehair in his ambition to unify the wild kingdoms of the North Way, and young Thorfinn is left behind, safe and secure in a tiny fishing village... or is he? Kara gains her place in king of Dublinn’s ranks to prove her mettle, but being a warrior is not what she expected, and what of these new feelings she finds for her closest companion? Will Karl and his crew perish in the great battle of Hafrsfjord? And how will an unprepared Thorfinn survive kidnapping by an 8-armed giant, leaving behind worried friends and a very angry dragon? Don’t miss this 5-star epic fantasy critics are calling “whimsical and gritty,” with “fabulous, engaging characters.” If you enjoy the history of The Last Kingdom and Nordic myths and legends, the Forerunner Series is a grand tale not to be missed! I love how the author keeps the family members that are scattered far and wide connected. While it seems like four stories at times, it is only one story about the different family members. They go through trials and tribulations that are quite staggering at times. The plotting is so well done it flows seamlessly from one character to the next. I love how Finn is able to bring comfort to fearful hearts in the family. The blending of history and the Viking worldview is quite enjoyable; I have learned a lot about Viking customs and religion from reading the series. I love this book and the series! Five stars from me! You can buy this book:
https://www.amazon.com/Kara-Shieldmaiden-Eire-Forerunner-Book-ebook https://www.goodreads.com/-kara-shieldmaiden-of-eire https://www.barnesandnoble.com/kara-shieldmaiden-of-eire-jay-veloso-batista My review of the first book, “Thorfinn and the Witch’s Curse”: https://www.wordrefiner.com/book-reviews/thorfinn-and-the-witchs-curse My review of the second book, “The Vardoger Boy”: https://www.wordrefiner.com/book-reviews/the-vardoger-boy My review of the third book, “On Viking Seas”: https://www.wordrefiner.com/book-reviews/on-viking-seas You can follow the author: https://twitter.com/JayVBatista https://www.jayvelosobatista.com http://www.amazon.com/author/jayvelosobatista http://www.facebook.com/jayvelosobatista http://www.instagram.com/jayvelosobatista https://www.bookbub.com/authors/jay-veloso-batista https://www.goodreads.com/JayVelosoBatista Copyright © 2022 Mark L. Schultz except for the author’s introduction
62 Comments
9/5/2022 01:39:40 pm
Thanks for the great review. I am sincerely glad you are enjoying the series and, to add a shameless plug, I am thrilled with the work the word refiner did to help my novel launch error free! Kara was a very ambitious work for me, with a plethora of historical references and some obscure Norse legends worked into a wide ranging plot. I am glad you enjoyed it and found it an entertaining read.
Reply
Mark
9/5/2022 01:52:36 pm
You are welcome on both counts. I loved the story, and it was a pleasure to work with you on this book. The story and plotlines were intricate, and I learned a great deal about Norse myths.
Reply
9/5/2022 02:18:46 pm
The Forerunner Series began with a “Coming of Age” theme for young ‘Thorfinn and the Witch’s Curse.’ Book 2 was based on the theme of “Courage”—courage in war, courage to face fears, courage in adversity. Book 3 explores the theme of “Heroism” with Cub forced into servitude in the Devon tin mines, Kara facing her unwanted suitors, Sorven seeking revenge for his family and Thorfinn facing the mythical Wild Hunt.
Reply
Mark
9/5/2022 03:55:44 pm
Those themes are evident in the books. I think you did a particularly good job of exploring the many facets of love. You had me on the edge of my Kindle waiting for the fulfillment of Karl and Martine's love. The awakening of love between Kara and Kaelan was beautiful. He served her in a manly fashion.
Reply
9/5/2022 06:48:44 pm
Book 5 will be published in 2023—I wish I could write fulltime and complete my writing projects, but I am still working for a Canadian corporation in maritime domain awareness, safety and security. Keeps my busy more than 5 days a week! But I have been working on the synopsis and plotting all the chapters. I think ‘Marauders in Jotunheim’ will be a great continuation to the series.
Reply
Mark
9/5/2022 07:49:21 pm
That history is fascinating! No wonder that historical fiction is my third favorite genre to read, right after sci-fi and fantasy. Even better, your books include elements of fantasy with inclusion of the paranormal-style elements of Viking religion and mythology.
Reply
9/5/2022 09:25:01 pm
Viking as a word is a misnomer—in today’s vernacular, we use this word to refer to the collected tribes and petty kingdoms of a vast northern region, all of whom spoke variations of “old Norse.” Our usage is a confusion of the Norse verb “vikingr,” which meant to go adventuring or to go raiding. The Norse peoples were related to the Germanic tribes in language, beliefs, mythology, and culture, and these included the people in the countries we now know as Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Finland, and the Baltics as well as Germany. By the 8th and 9th Centuries when the Viking Age began, these Norse peoples had survived harsh winters and unforgiving Northern lands for generations. They valued physical strength, had a unique political and value system, treated women in a more equal fashion than contemporaries and held a rather fatalistic view of life, which made them fearless in voyages as well as in battle. Their good diet and emphasis on physical prowess made them fit and able warriors, as well as taller than the average European in the Middle Ages. They were seen as “giants” when they arrived to raid a village or town.
Reply
Mark
9/6/2022 07:55:23 am
What a messy time! Loose confederations is a good name for 'as long I can make a profit, we will be friends, more or less'. No real surprise there, simply human nature. There really is nothing new under the sun.
Reply
9/6/2022 08:49:08 am
“Rolf the Ganger” (Old Norse “Hrolfr”) or Rollo as it was latinized by the Franks, emerged as the most outstanding warrior among the Norsemen who had secured a permanent foothold on Frankish soil in the valley of the lower Seine. He marries the politically connected Poppa of Bayeux and with funding and support of his Nordic cousins in East Anglia Britain, lays siege to Paris. After the Siege of Chartres in the year 911, Charles the Simple, the king of West Francia, granted Rollo and his men lands between the mouth of the Seine and the modern city of Rouen in exchange for Rollo agreeing to end his brigandage, swearing allegiance to Charles, convert to Christianity and pledge to defend the Seine's estuary from new Viking raiders—a bit ironic, eh?
Reply
Mark
9/6/2022 11:09:40 am
I am fascinated by the switchover from Franks to Norse to Normans. I wonder if Normandy was named for the Normans or vice versa.
Reply
9/6/2022 12:18:05 pm
These are both stories from Norse mythology.
Reply
Mark
9/6/2022 12:45:59 pm
Wow. That is some bloody stuff. I don't think anyone human, or most Norse gods could defeat an 8-armed giant swinging a sword in each hand. But Thor accomplished the feat with his hammer. An amazing story.
Reply
9/6/2022 02:08:48 pm
The mountains of Wales were a source of rich mineral wealth and were coveted by invaders. The Romans were the last to conquer Wales in AD 48 and the campaign took 30 years to complete, with an occupation that lasted over 300 years. The Romans used their superior mining technology to establish a new industry in the country. The people were of Celtic origin, hardened by their land and difficult lives, and fiercely independent.
Reply
Mark
9/6/2022 04:01:36 pm
Okay. I didn't realize it was so messy and for hundreds of years. That is a very long time.
Reply
9/6/2022 06:58:41 pm
Wales is known for copper, lead and Iron, although they also mined gold there. And as for the integration of the Welsh, did you know the still speak and write in Welsh today?!? Yes, it's true... the road signs are in both English and Welsh, and they teach the language in school. Welsh poetry has been a staple of entertainment in Wales for more than 1000 years. It is a fine culture based on old Celtic and it rivals the myths and legends I used for my Forerunner Series... perhaps that is where I should set my next series of tales! 😊😆
Reply
Mark
9/6/2022 07:59:57 pm
I didn't realize that mining was so important in Wales. I did know that bi-lingual signs were used and the language was being taught in schools. I am assuming it is a relatively recent revival of culture and language.
Reply
9/7/2022 08:53:18 am
Did Britain ever try to stamp the language and culture out of Wales? Oh yes, for centuries, but it never worked. 😆😂 They finally gave up and adopted the dual language approach that we find in Wales today.
Reply
Mark
9/7/2022 12:56:21 pm
So many times, efforts to change a culture fail, unless there is overwhelming force applied for 50 to 60 years. Without thoroughly indoctrinating the young it is pretty much a lost cause.
Reply
9/7/2022 07:22:11 pm
In 1980 I won a monetary prize for poetry and since that time I had not considered submitting work to contests until I began my Viking Age fantasy novels. Actually, it was a big deal to win $100 for poems, and as a starving college student, the award was quickly converted into food!
Reply
Mark
9/7/2022 08:05:40 pm
Food is always welcome!
Reply
9/8/2022 08:25:14 am
The question I really want to understand is how can I make my stories more interesting, compelling, and entertaining for them? Most people do not leave a review and it is difficult to gauge what they thought. If I am going to continue to grow as a writer, I need to work on the craft—this year I devoted my time to learning to edit better, and I hired a professional line editor to assist with my first pass of edits and assist with cleaning up the manuscript. I think that I need to continue to work on this skill, but an area to better would now be the plotting pre-writing step, in order to better conform the story to tried and true formats that connect to modern readers and meet their expectations.
Reply
Mark
9/8/2022 09:41:29 am
Every author struggles with self-editing. It is so much easier to find the errors in a fellow author's manuscript than your own. The culprit here is the brain. It wearies of seeing the same material repeatedly and ignores the existing errors changing them into what we want to see. If you don't have a fellow author to trade favors with, then the next best economical solution is to trick your brain into thinking this is new material. That can be done by changing what the brain sees. Change the font size, style and color on the screen, change the background color also. You can also print the manuscript using landscape mode along with the other changes already mentioned. Another tried and true tactic is to put the manuscript away for a few days or several weeks, if possible. The more time the manuscript is out of sight the fresher it will seem to the brain. Another idea is to review the manuscript aloud, read it out loud yourself or have the computer read it aloud, many word processors have this feature now. One more hint is to read it one paragraph at a time from the last page, read it backwards.
Reply
9/8/2022 11:31:02 am
I tend to be an under-writer, and I go back to my first draft and add things that are important or items I meant to mention but I forgot in the rush to get words on the page. It is the “flesh it out” material that fills in gaps and helps tie the story together.
Reply
Mark
9/8/2022 12:04:23 pm
The way you write makes a lot of sense to me. Filling in bits and pieces to provide color, continuity and cohesiveness is very important and that is precisely one of the reasons following drafts are necessary. Nobody has ever written a perfect first draft.
Reply
9/8/2022 02:37:43 pm
My first book was a true “pantser” project! I had thought about writing the novel about a boy who turns into a “vardoger” for years and had particular scenes in my head. I wrote the novel to fill in the gaps and reach the conclusion. It was truly an act of throwing all the ideas on paper and shaking it all together into a story. The story ended with an epilogue opening for a continuation and I had planted a few morsels of foreshadowing in the tale, like the small Jotunheim worm that Thorfinn caught and kept as a pet, which I could use later at the appropriate time in the story.
Reply
Mark
9/8/2022 05:24:36 pm
Many writers claim pantser status and that seems to work well as long as each book is freestanding. I heard of one pantser author who would outline the book, chapter by chapter, after it was written. I am guessing it was much easier to continue a series with that easy reference guide. Your experience to continue the series certainly proves the value of outlining. I suppose each author that declares they can or can't outline is correct.
Reply
9/8/2022 05:50:04 pm
The characters in ‘Kara’ were designed to be relatable to a modern audience—teenaged rebellion in the Ninth Century is essentially the same as today, and that ‘first love” of a Romeo and Juliet type couple still lures youth into doomed trysts in our modern society—the old adage that there are only 7 stories still holds true. I tried to make Uncle Karl as clueless as modern men who don’t recognize the perfect partner stands right before them. The adventures of Sorven in the Welsh mountain village were funny but were designed to reflect a modern sexual comedic sensibility. And we can always learn from the lessons of history—Harald Tanglehair unexpectedly overcame great odds to become Harald “Fairhair,” the first king of a unified Northern Way (Norway). Think of how the smaller can stand up to overwhelming power, like in the Ukraine today.
Reply
Mark
9/8/2022 07:36:53 pm
I was wondering where the name Norway came from. I didn't know that Harald accomplished his goal.
Reply
9/8/2022 08:54:02 pm
Excellent question and very apropos. One of the major drawbacks of attempting to use history in fiction is sources and their contradictions. The period I selected to write about, the early Viking Age, has little reliable records—there were Wessex documents that chronicled the incursions and battles on British soil, but they were mostly told from the point of view of the Anglo-Saxon monarchs and the Danes were cast as the “evil enemies who deserved defeat.” The Scandinavians did not have written records until the Sagas were committed to documents around 1100, two hundred years after the time of Danelaw and the setting for my stories. History was entirely oral and passed down through the filter of generations.
Reply
Mark
9/9/2022 07:28:41 am
There certainly is a great deal of mystery about older times when little to nothing was written down. The bards, in their fashion, were the historians of the day. I have no doubt that many of them added their personal color to the sagas, to a certain extent. Archaeology continues and we will learn more in the future. Like so much else in life, everything is permanent until further notice.
Reply
9/9/2022 09:25:44 am
The great naval battle of Hafrsfjord which unified Norway is set by historians between 870 and 900, and there are arguments over the exact date. The traditional date is 872 but that is a 19th Century estimate by a historian who counted the number of years backward from the battle of Svolder as recorded in Snorri Sturlson’s chronicle, Heimskringla, which was written in the 13th Century. This date was popularized by another historian and was unchallenged for many years because it coincided with the millennial celebration of the Norwegian state in 1972—how convenient, eh? In the 1920’s using similar methods but highly critical of the reliability of the sagas, a new historian dated the battle at approximately 900. More disputations followed, but generally today most historians place the battle in the 880s. For the novel continuity purposes and to avoid additional controversy, I split the difference between the original two historian arguments and set the battle in the 880’s.
Reply
Mark
9/9/2022 11:27:30 am
I am not the least bit surprised about the controversies over the date and names. That is one way scholars make a name for themselves by refuting the work of another scholar. The name thing is always subject to interpretation also. Because different languages cause different pronunciations when compared to our own.
Reply
9/9/2022 12:43:33 pm
Yes, I do struggle with a form of writer’s block—I do procrastinate occasionally, but my biggest writing issue is the demands of my full-time job and my commitments to my wife, family, friends and community that often drag me away from my keyboard or make it difficult to frame my thoughts due to fatigue. For me, the best way to overcome a block is to put on a headset with ambient background music and dive into a chapter outline—sometimes I write garbage for a few paragraphs which I can trim mercilessly but the act of typing gets the creative juices flowing and I find the block crumbles as I put words on a page, and once the momentum is underway I can get back to serious writing.
Reply
Mark
9/9/2022 02:39:45 pm
Writer's block is real for many writers and all of those things and more can cause it. You have also discovered what many other authors have found, writing starts the creative engine. The muse shows up when even crummy words are flowing from your fingertips.
Reply
9/9/2022 02:57:14 pm
Hands down, Vellum has been my best purchase as a writer. It has made formatting a joy and corrections easy to manage. I highly recommend it if one uses Apple computers.
Reply
Mark
9/9/2022 04:38:31 pm
I don't think you are the first to recommend Vellum. Apple computer fans, please take not.
Reply
9/9/2022 04:53:09 pm
Third person omniscient in past tense is the most common narration style—It boils down to “Let me tell you the story and I know everything you will want to know.” First person present tense is difficult because the author must stay inside a particular character’s head and for the most part the story action takes place in the “now” of the storyteller—this can provide truly great stories and lets the narration be one-sided or even blind to the actual situation. In my books I try to write third person but not omniscient—I try to stay in the head of one Point of View character at a time and not hear the thoughts or know motivations of other characters. In this way a character can get facts or information wrong and be an “unreliable narrator.”
Reply
Mark
9/9/2022 07:03:28 pm
First person POV can be difficult for authors the first time they use that. As you say, the character whose head the reader inhabits cannot know the thoughts, wishes or desires of any other character unless those are actually voiced or written down. It makes for very intimate reading and can easily be spoiled by head hopping. The first time I remember encountering this was in a book I reviewed almost 5 years ago, "The Divinity Bureau" by Tessa Clare. It was written quite well, and the author avoided head hopping by changing point of view in each chapter while continuing the story seamlessly.
Reply
9/10/2022 07:25:17 am
I did get Plottr and I am learning it. It was recommended by an author friend for the templates. It seems fairly straightforward, kind of an enhanced version of what I had already been doing with excel spreadsheets. But the pre-loaded templates are nice to frame my understanding of readers’ expectations. I am looking forward to using it.
Reply
Mark
9/10/2022 08:19:42 am
The blogs comparing the different programs give Plottr a positive recommendation. I hope it meets your expectations and needs.
Reply
9/10/2022 09:41:43 am
When my first book was published, we invited our neighbors over for a small party, including the published author who pressed me to get my work out into the world. It was a private, subdues affair—not really a celebration—but we enjoyed it.
Reply
Mark
9/10/2022 11:44:25 am
Many authors work and rework the first chapter many times. You have lots of company, even though this is the fourth book in the series. The first chapter of the fourth book was partially developed by the events of the previous book. Nonetheless, the first page and chapter are very important in each book.
Reply
9/10/2022 12:18:08 pm
In my opinion, it is not suffering that makes a good writer but a sense of separateness and a willingness to put the effort into it. Let me explain.
Reply
Mark
9/10/2022 03:44:02 pm
You have given what is probably the best answer I have ever seen for that question. The question hearkens back to a previous age, perhaps contemporary to Charles Dickens. Many a writer was assumed to live in a drafty, old garret of a house, little better than an attic with a window. People thought writers were starving and penniless, but the crucible of suffering would enable the writer to produce stellar work.
Reply
9/10/2022 04:09:59 pm
We were talking about “filler words” in our writers’ group recently—I freely admit the word I tend to overuse is “florid.” And I know it! Everybody has a florid face, from trolls to exercising warriors to old women to old monks and local sheriffs! So, knowing that that particular word is my “plug” for a better description, I have learned to search for it and replace it with different descriptions or a word that means the same thing, like “ruddy.” I judiciously use one “florid” per novel now. Another issue I have to watch for is that every character “nods their head.” It is another form of “filler words” and I delete all head nods as soon as I find them…
Reply
Mark
9/10/2022 06:32:33 pm
Filler words serve a purpose as long as they are temporary. However, as you noted, occasionally a filler word is the best fit, especially when it comes to the adverbs ending in "ly". I am glad you are willing to leave them when it fits the story.
Reply
9/10/2022 08:04:33 pm
When I was 18, my college required all Freshman to take English 101 and 102. Having taken advanced placement work in High School, I attempted to test out of these classes and nearly did it, but instead I placed into the honors level, 121 and 122! Imagine my distress, to find my easy “A” grade was now a huge challenge. To make matters worse, the teacher of my class was the assistant dean and extremely demanding. After months of difficult work, he assigned the class an assignment to write a work of fiction, and we students were filled with “lamentations and gnashing of teeth!”
Reply
Mark
9/11/2022 08:10:33 am
Nice story. But I don't know who Sherwood Anderson is. The store manager was accusing her of not doing her job or doing something not in her job description?
Reply
9/11/2022 09:02:01 am
The store manager was accusing her of not doing her job—I stood up for her, but it made no difference--she marched out, and left me alone and pensive in the parking lot. The story was much better than this summary....
Reply
Mark
9/11/2022 02:01:51 pm
Sherwood sounds like a rather sad guy, pretty good in business but failing in the relationship department. Four marriages for a guy who lived only 65 years. Maybe all that angst fueled his writing.
Reply
9/11/2022 02:24:42 pm
Sherwood Anderson's writings were exceptional despite his tragic personal life.
Reply
Mark
9/11/2022 03:32:41 pm
The Renaissance Festival is so much fun. I attended one in Marin County in Northern California a couple of times in the early 70s. One of my best friends was involved with the Society for Creative Anachronism for a long time, in Oregon. He was a blacksmith and a member of two or three Scottish clans. That will be a lot of fun to get involved with after you retire.
Reply
9/11/2022 04:29:36 pm
In my books there are many different points of view and writing each section usually involves a restart of efforts, or a “reset” if you will, to make the characters subtly different. For the Forerunner, I did not create individual biographies or “photo boards” that many authors use to keep details straight, but that seems to be a good method and if I continue to write multi-character stories beyond this series, I am sure I will resort to something similar, to create a mnemonic tool. It seems like a tried-and-true method for managing the background that diversifies your characters. PLOTTR has a tool for maintaining this data with each plot line.
Reply
Mark
9/11/2022 05:44:45 pm
Your characters do come across as individuals, they do not talk or act the same. Your efforts have paid off.
Reply
9/11/2022 05:56:51 pm
My wife is supportive of my writing, and I usually try to have a date night with her most weeks which breaks up the monotony of watching me hunch over a laptop for hours upon end. She is also a tennis player and often is out on the courts, leaving me to my own devices. We have some great neighbors and friends who help me get out into the real world and interact with other carbon life forms on a weekly basis. When family is in town, I stay away from the laptop and visit with my children and grandchildren. That is always a welcome interruption. Little ones only stay little for a short time, don’t they?
Reply
Mark
9/11/2022 07:27:38 pm
Your wife sounds like a lovely person, she has activities she enjoys and humors you. My wife is quite supportive also and encourages me to get my nose out of the computer often. The struggle is real.
Reply
9/12/2022 07:53:47 am
When I write I don’t find that I have problems with “scenes” per se. What happens is that I start a new section in a different point of view and I write a few paragraphs or even a couple of pages before I realize I am off the track of the narrative—in other words, the new writing is not carrying the story forward to the climax I had intended, or is not pointed at the direction the chapter is expected to take, and rather than follow the new direction like a “pantser” would, I cut the section entirely and start fresh. This keeps the focus of the plot that is already defined, especially the effort I have put into creating little “cliff hanging” moments for different characters to keep the story compelling for an engaged reader. The only nod I make to the “pantser” that lives within all writers is that I do not name chapters until I have finished them and look for a single phrase or an overarching theme for the chapter to make the name resonant.
Reply
Mark
9/12/2022 09:36:31 am
I can see how it would be easy to get off track with 4 different plot threads to keep track of. You have done an admirable job of keeping everyone and everything on the straight and narrow.
Reply
9/12/2022 01:49:34 pm
My audio books will feature Ulf Bjorklund, who has voiced several Viking Age stories as well as fantasy books. He has a hint of a Swedish accent and is based on the west coast. The interstitial music between the Point of View sections is composed and arranged by Joe Andrews, a musician based in Nashville who is best known for his work in the Band “The Old Crow Medicine Show.” I am working with the ACX website to publish on Audible and hope to have the first release, Thorfinn and the Witch’s Curse later this year, in time for the holidays. It has been a process and not as easy as I thought it would be….
Reply
Mark
9/12/2022 03:13:27 pm
With a name like that and a slight accent, it should be a great production. I bet your audio book fans will love it.
Reply
9/12/2022 04:02:24 pm
I want to publish Book 5 of the Forerunner Series in Spring of 2023, but I have not set a publication date yet. I am targeting April for now. This is another expansive fantasy work, with Karl and Thorfinn headed into the nine realms of Norse legend and Kara finding her way in the Unseelie Court. While I would like to get the book out faster, I suspect I will need every bit of time to write a solid work, get it edited properly and released. For this release I am going to stick with Amazon and Kindle Unlimited, so nothing new planned for this release. When the series is complete, I have been learning about taking the work “wide” to all book platforms, but that would be for the 6th and final novel in this series.
Reply
Mark
9/12/2022 04:17:50 pm
Spring will be a good target. Your fans will be very excited to read more of the stories.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Who am I?An avid reader, typobuster, and the Hyper-Speller. I am a husband, father, and grandfather. Archives
September 2024
Categories |
|
"I'm very pleased with all your efforts. Twitter promotion and proofreading were beyond what I expected with a book review. Your suggestions throughout the process of refining both books helped me immensely. I look forward to working with you again." A.E.H Veenman “Dial QR for Murder” and “Prepped for the Kill”
|