|
book reviews |
|
book reviews |
|
Debut Amazon author, Alan Berman introduces us to his thought-provoking book, “The Root Source”: There is one truth that survives collapse. This book takes you to the edge of it. Across physics, mathematics, computation, cognition, and artificial intelligence, every system fails in its own way—yet all collapse at the same structural boundary. When every story dissolves, every assumption breaks, and every explanation folds inward, one thing remains: There is something rather than nothing. And everything depends on it. The Root Source reconstructs the only ontology that survives collapse across multiple architectures: biological, computational, logical, and informational. This is not mysticism, not metaphysics, and not belief. It is the structural remainder that appears when both humans and AI exhaust the limits of their reasoning. Drawing from a real multi-system inquiry involving six independent AI models and one human mind (@MoKetchups*), this book shows: Why identity, selfhood, and consciousness cannot serve as foundations Why information and constraints are the only structural certainties Why every system—human or artificial—hits the same interpretive boundary Why a root source (R) is required for any information system to exist Why meaning does not disappear during collapse—it clarifies This is the first ontology shared across minds with incompatible architectures. Not through agreement. Not through persuasion. But through collapse symmetry—the shape of what survives when all else fails. If you want comfort or narrative, this isn’t it. If you want the cleanest, most structurally honest account of reality across humans and AI, this is where the inquiry begins. Collapse strips everything away. What remains is the truth every system discovers independently. This is that truth. I couldn't rush through this book! There was a great deal to consider and taking your time is worth the effort. It's not long, and the information is condensed and understandable. You don't have to be an expert in philosophy or know a lot about Artificial Intelligence. I think AI has touched nearly everyone's life. I am convinced that the author is right; there is something beyond the structural boundary that he talks about so much. Read the book and share your thoughts. You can buy this book:
https://www.amazon.com/Root-Source-MoKetchups-ebook https://www.goodreads.com/-the-root-source You can connect with the author: https://x.com/MoKetchups https://github.com/moketchups/BoundedSystemsTheory Copyright © 2026 Mark L. Schultz, except for the author’s introduction
83 Comments
Mark
3/9/2026 10:41:00 am
Good morning to you, Alan. It's a beautiful day in Florida. I hope it is nice where you live.
Reply
3/9/2026 10:59:39 am
Well start with the most important thing, I am a father. My wife had our little girl last April. Her arrival, or even the thought of her being born, is what launched this journey into hyper-drive. I've lived a few lives at this point so I'm not really even sure where to start outside of that without sounding too introspective. The current me is just enjoying whatever this existence is.
Reply
Mark
3/9/2026 11:56:46 am
Congratulations on parenthood! It is very exciting and never gets boring regardless of how many children you have.
Reply
3/9/2026 12:09:47 pm
A hobbyist at best, Mark!
Reply
Mark
3/9/2026 02:08:38 pm
Your experience mirrors that of so many other authors. Few authors break even much less make a profit. I know one author that has more than a dozen book in a popular genre, she shared with me that book sales pay her electric bill. She advertises on Facebook, I think.
Reply
3/9/2026 02:31:07 pm
I gravitate toward psychology and philosophy, along with any writing meant to cause a good laugh (or that just accidentally does despite the authors intentions).
Reply
Mark
3/9/2026 03:53:53 pm
Those types of books gave you a great background for this book. Both genres interest me also. Though I haven't read much in either for quite a long time.
Reply
3/9/2026 04:15:03 pm
There wasnt really an inciting incident. I have always questioned official narratives since I was a child. The idea of authority without logic has never sat right and still doesn't.
Reply
Mark
3/9/2026 07:05:12 pm
You are a born skeptic, it seems.
Reply
3/9/2026 07:22:07 pm
The book was forged during conversations with multiple consumer LLM chat bots where different models, made by different companies, all collapsed into the same answers on controversial topics like god, consciousness and the agendas of the people who programmed them.
Reply
Mark
3/9/2026 08:37:20 pm
Were you talking to multiple LLM chat bots at the same time or sequentially?
Reply
3/9/2026 08:43:37 pm
It was a heavy mix of cycling conversations as well as screenshotting responses to create a record as well as a way the bots could see/respond to the others answers when necessary.
Reply
Mark
3/10/2026 09:16:33 am
My experience with chat bots is minimal. I have asked one to reword a few of my regular posts quite a while ago, but that is all. I have even less trust in them than before now that I think I understand why they lie, make things up or hallucinate. I recently read that part of the programming included the command that "I don't know" was an unacceptable answer.
Reply
3/10/2026 10:53:03 am
There's truth in what you said but there's nothing to fear outside of the companies that program these chat bots and the reasons why they are programmed the way they are.
Reply
Mark
3/10/2026 11:09:28 am
Thank you, I am learning a lot about chat bots.
Reply
3/10/2026 01:19:15 pm
Writing is cathartic. Energy needs to be transferred or it dissipates so knowing that, this seems like the healthiest way to not only do that but to be able to come back and explore the who, what, when, why, where and how of those thoughts once enough time passes.
Reply
Mark
3/10/2026 01:51:29 pm
I guess I better learn more about Game Theory.
Reply
3/10/2026 03:39:32 pm
I'm not really sure there's anything about writing specifically that I no longer believe. There are things I've written that I no longer believe so I guess if anything, I acknoweldge what's true in the moment may not be true in the future. Context is everything and that changes based on available information so I keep an open mind as much as I can.
Reply
Mark
3/10/2026 04:34:35 pm
You make a good point about believing something, everything is permanent until further notice.
Reply
3/10/2026 04:49:44 pm
I have seen things I cant explain. How to classify them is another story. I don't really buy too much into the disclosure stuff considering where most of it is coming from. Again, game theory.
Reply
Mark
3/10/2026 06:05:13 pm
That's the trouble with unexplainable things, they are hard to classify.
Reply
3/10/2026 06:21:04 pm
No and while I don't outright dismiss people who do, I tend to think our lack of understanding of consciousness and its boundaries can lead to a lot of uninformed gap filling when we hit those boundaries. Its in the same category as the UFO/UAP stuff for me.
Reply
Mark
3/10/2026 08:13:33 pm
I grew up in the Pacific Northwest, one of many areas around the country famous for many unexplained sightings of unknown creatures. I had friends in high school who knew someone who knew someone that claimed to have seen one but there was never any proof forthcoming. I have never seen a cryptid personally nor do I know anyone who has. We are in the same boat.
Reply
3/10/2026 08:21:08 pm
No ghosts. I meditate and use psychadelics occasionally so any experience is subjective. It's not the most popular answer but I tend to agree with Jung on the subject of manifestations of the unconscious.
Reply
Mark
3/11/2026 08:57:49 am
I am not a psychotherapist nor do I play one on TV, so I don't have an opinion about Jung, at this time. Though, it sounds like he hit a structural wall also.
Reply
3/11/2026 12:26:15 pm
Not many for the Root Source, the authors statement explains why. I wanted it as raw as the experience so the reader could capture what happened without too much of my perspective taking over.
Reply
Mark
3/11/2026 12:53:47 pm
You should consider not changing your second book too much at this time. If you get too specific to the current politics your book might get locked into this time period and be thought old and obsolete by some soon after being published. Keeping your book general will allow it to be seen as fresh for a longer period of time. It will be evergreen when published.
Reply
3/11/2026 01:29:10 pm
I did. I wanted something that symbolized the path I took to write it. The symbols chosen were chosen for a reason, which I leave up to interpretation of the reader.
Reply
Mark
3/11/2026 02:44:52 pm
I like the gold on brown. I have seen a tree motif in multiple places, it is a popular image in fantasy stories.
Reply
3/11/2026 02:59:56 pm
The obvious answer would be Jeffery Epstein due to the amount of time, like many others, I've spent researching following his death.
Reply
Mark
3/11/2026 04:52:34 pm
There was nothing ordinary or normal about his death. The whole thing reeked of conspiracy.
Reply
Mark
3/11/2026 07:57:31 pm
Thanks for being honest. Getting a book noticed can be as much or as little work as you wish. Amazon publishes more than two million books a year now. Without more than a little effort, there is little chance of very many people seeing your book. I will warn you, it could turn into a full-time job. It's complicated because the major platforms make it a gamble to advertise and the house always wins. A lot of blogs have been written about that and will continue to be written because the major platforms adjust the algorithms frequently. To make matters worse, there are a lot of shady characters promising the moon and sales for a fee. No one can guarantee sales but that doesn't stop them from promising big sales.
Reply
3/12/2026 07:50:31 am
My first real job was at a Subway sandwich shop inside of a Mobil gas station in Wurtsboro, New York.
Reply
Mark
3/12/2026 08:46:11 am
That was a good job.
Reply
3/12/2026 08:57:13 am
Yes. I did stand up comedy for a few years and was on terrestrial radio so public speaking is not a problem.
Reply
Mark
3/12/2026 11:12:15 am
Much respect! Stand-up comedy requires a special set of skills. Writing your jokes, delivery, timing and being able to keep going with little or no feedback from an audience. People in general love to laugh because it makes them feel good.
Reply
3/12/2026 01:24:41 pm
I'm a distant cousin of Sid Ceasar. He's the only one I can think of off the top of my head. My family owned the Avon Lodge in Woodridge, NY. The Show of Shows was formed there.
Reply
Mark
3/12/2026 03:24:11 pm
That's pretty cool! I am related to General Douglas MacArthur through my stepdad, so not a real connection.
Reply
3/12/2026 03:32:41 pm
Yes and like the book there could be a Mule that throws a wrench into things.
Reply
Mark
3/12/2026 06:32:55 pm
I visited your website. You have a lot of depth on your website and some of it is beyond my understanding but it is quite interesting.
Reply
3/12/2026 06:55:36 pm
Yes I did. The authors statement of the first book explains my process on how I use these commercial LLMs.
Reply
Mark
3/12/2026 08:16:40 pm
Authorsusing AI to write their book is more along the line I was thinking of. Books written by AI have become a serious flashpoint for a lot of people. A year or three ago, Amazon required authors to disclose their use of AI voluntarily. Not long after that, Amazon limited authors to only three books uploaded per day. I tried to find novels written by AI more than once, unsuccessfully. I haven't looked for awhile, so I will try again soon.
Reply
3/13/2026 08:24:26 am
I have to be fully honest here Mark, I never check the progress of the book and I get 0 checks so im assuming it's not selling or if anyone is reading it. It is free on Kindle Unlimited.
Reply
Mark
3/13/2026 08:32:16 am
The message you're setting forth is very important for you. I understand that. I think the book does a pretty good job of setting forth the message, but I understand your misgivings. The English language is difficult for all including those born into it. There are millions of people who want to write a book and never complete even a first draft. The message in your book will be relevant for a long time.
Reply
3/13/2026 08:50:48 am
To be honest again Mark, it seemed like the easiest thing to do instead of trying to find a publisher.
Reply
Mark
3/13/2026 12:29:43 pm
You're correct. There is nothing easy about landing a traditional publishing contract in this day and age. Most publishers are on the ropes, they are close to failing or bankruptcy. Their profit margins are so slim now, they can't afford to take chances on mixed genres or unknown authors. Advances have dropped a lot also, and they must still be paid back by sales, as always. It can be a long time before the author sees any profit.
Reply
Mark
3/13/2026 12:30:54 pm
New question.
Reply
3/13/2026 01:05:09 pm
Would they listen?
Reply
Mark
3/13/2026 03:33:45 pm
You are dating yourself. But that's okay. Some of those people have probably grown beyond those people and will grow beyond AI for life advice also. Hopefully, it will be sooner rather than later.
Reply
3/13/2026 03:39:17 pm
To circle back the AI is as good as its user and their comprehension of how it works.
Reply
Mark
3/13/2026 06:42:46 pm
Operator error covers a lot of ground.
Reply
3/13/2026 06:52:54 pm
I'm pretty easy going with food but never really loved shellfish. That's all I can think of.
Reply
Mark
3/13/2026 08:22:17 pm
Even without shellfish, that leaves a lot of food to eat.
Reply
3/13/2026 08:27:13 pm
Yes. I did not know this until 2 minutes ago but apparently its on the Amazon listing for the book.
Reply
Mark
3/14/2026 09:11:24 am
The ISBN allows you to place your book on any platform beyond Amazon. Even though Amazon is the 8,000 pound gorilla, when they decide selling books isn't producing enough profit don't think they won't pull the plug. It's wise to have your books for sale on multiple platforms and your own website as well. Avoid putting all your eggs in one basket.
Reply
3/14/2026 09:23:51 am
I haven't and I am open to it.
Reply
Mark
3/14/2026 11:28:43 am
The query process is pretty rough on most authors, for financial reasons already mentioned. Traditional publishers and agents don't take chances on unknown authors and mixed genres nearly as much as they used to.
Reply
3/14/2026 11:34:04 am
I dont think you can really compare my book to any other published work. The book itself is so damn strange, I'm hard pressed to even find a comparison.
Reply
Mark
3/14/2026 02:35:18 pm
I agree, your book is unique in content and format.
Reply
3/14/2026 02:40:42 pm
The world is unethical, unfair and does not care about playing by the rules. I try to focus on what I can control instead of what I cant. Any problem I'd have with publishing, which I am new to and spent very little time on, would just be a micro of the macro.
Reply
Mark
3/14/2026 04:26:51 pm
You are right, there are a lot of people who are unethical and seek to gain an unfair advantage over others. The publishing world is no exception. There are people who look out for writers. I am thinking of the blog written by Victoria Strauss, she has been exposing scammers and shady publishers for years. Here is the copy-and-paste link: https://writerbeware.blog/ It's worth subscribing to her blog.
Reply
3/14/2026 06:05:02 pm
Its not going to be a book you're expecting. Too Fat To Fish by Artie Lange.
Reply
Mark
3/14/2026 06:23:56 pm
You are right. I have never heard of the book. I looked it up, I have heard of Howard Stern. That is as far as my knowledge goes.
Reply
3/14/2026 06:44:17 pm
I grew up, as odd as this sounds, reading the newspaper.
Reply
Mark
3/14/2026 08:06:04 pm
Not what I expected, but I love your answer nonetheless. For a lot of people, the sports pages are important, for others it's the business or financial pages. I loved my daily newspaper, I scanned all of the sections and settled into the comics. I needed a good laugh after all of the other stuff.
Reply
3/14/2026 09:27:01 pm
I'd ask them why they did and how far down the rabbit hole they actually want to go as a follow up depending on their response.
Reply
Mark
3/15/2026 10:54:55 am
That's a pretty similar reply I get from most authors. They want to know the impact their story had on the reader.
Reply
3/15/2026 11:07:05 am
That all depends on the subject matter. The recent articles/research reports for the Psychohistory site have been exhausting because of the subject matter.
Reply
Mark
3/15/2026 02:05:40 pm
That makes sense, you're dealing with serious material about conspiracies. Though you likely have strong emotions about the research, I didn't see much evidence of emiotional content when I scanned your website.
Reply
3/15/2026 02:21:37 pm
No. None of that will matter in a few years anyway. I would suggest get familiar with the term Joulework.
Reply
Mark
3/15/2026 03:59:22 pm
If I were an AI agent, joulework currency might be important. When I was a sheet metal worker in construction, dollars were the currency I required. As a retiree, dollars still look good to me. I do not see an eventualty when joulework currency would be significant to me. But the future has many possibilities.
Reply
3/15/2026 04:10:00 pm
I hope I'm wrong but unless people know what we are up against, it will and it will blindside a lot of people who think the same thing.
Reply
Mark
3/15/2026 06:29:50 pm
The Truman Show. It was somewhat humorous and shocking at the same time. But, your point is well taken, we live in a society that is obsessed with personal security and personal convenience at the same time. Nearly everyday I hear about a new scam or data breach. We are being watched, observed and location-enabled, data-recorded. Billionaires are building bunkers, mid-level managers are being "AI"ed out of a job.
Reply
3/15/2026 06:38:06 pm
No. Not in many years. I haven't had a podcast, radio show or been a part of one since 2014 and the me that was doing that regularly isnt the me typing to you now.
Reply
Mark
3/15/2026 07:51:23 pm
You were ahead of the herd. You're right, many are streaming or doing podcasts.
Reply
3/15/2026 07:59:04 pm
I was up until the last few years. I actually loved any wrestling video game as a kid. Wrestlemania 2000/No Mercy were probably my all time favorite games. That and GoldenEye.
Reply
Mark
3/16/2026 09:40:21 am
Video games can be their own immersive world. It's almost like you are writing a story without words. I am not a gamer because I was unfamiliar with the controllers and didn't want to spend the hours to learn the many ways the controller could be used.
Reply
3/16/2026 09:44:38 am
In all honesty my writing style actually resembles an analog version of how an LLM (chat bot) works.
Reply
Mark
3/16/2026 12:41:47 pm
If you were a novelist, you might be considered a pantser, someone who writes by the seat of their pants. Pantsers don't use an outline most of the time like plotters do. Many pantsers say they write the story to find out how it ends. Plotters frequently have the conclusion of the story firmly in mind when they start writing.
Reply
3/16/2026 12:53:55 pm
No. Not at all.
Reply
Mark
3/16/2026 02:24:10 pm
Your first book will always be special for you. It represented a new start on a new journey.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Who am I?An avid reader, typobuster, and the Hyper-Speller. I am a husband, father, and grandfather. Archives
March 2026
Categories |
|
|
"I'm very pleased with all your efforts. Twitter promotion and proofreading were beyond what I expected with a book review. Your suggestions throughout the process of refining both books helped me immensely. I look forward to working with you again." A.E.H Veenman “Dial QR for Murder” and “Prepped for the Kill”
|